The Timeless Appeal of Romance
With their undeniable, universal appeal, romance novels transcend generations and literary trends. The genre consistently dominates the literary landscape, making up 23% of all book sales in the U.S.—the most of any genre. This lasting popularity stems from its unique ability to engage readers on a deeply emotional level. At its core, romance explores the universal human desire for love, connection, and intimacy, offering both an escape and a reflection of real-life experiences.
Classic examples like Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen highlight the timelessness of romance, while modern hits like The Notebook by Nicholas Sparks show how new love stories continue to move readers just as deeply as they ever did, across generations. This mix of emotional depth and universal appeal makes romance a genre with both lasting popularity and creative flexibility for writers.
Identifying Your Audience: Writing for Their Hearts
Romance readers are diverse, with preferences ranging from classic love stories to modern, creative, and unconventional narratives. You’ll want to gain a clear understanding of the specific audience you are writing for. If you’re not sure you’re your audience is, consider comparable titles—other books that influenced, inspired, or that share similarities with your writing. A look at their fanbase and marketing may help you determine your own target audience. However, one thing all romance readers expect is a palpable sense of emotional connection between characters. Today, many readers also want more than familiar tropes—they seek diverse relationships and authentic human experiences.
As Colleen Hoover puts it, “You’re not just telling a love story—you’re telling a human story.” Julia Quinn of Bridgerton highlights the “promise of hope and the journey to that hope,” emphasizing that emotional arcs keep readers invested.
To connect with your audience, research bestseller lists, engage on platforms like Goodreads, and explore reader reviews. Each subgenre draws different readers: historical romance offers escapism, while contemporary and romantic suspense caters to readers who enjoy modern, fast-paced themes.
Creating Unforgettable Characters: Love Begins with Relatability
Romance readers connect with characters who feel real—flawed, vulnerable, and emotionally complex. Characters facing internal conflicts, like trust issues or past heartbreak, heighten emotional stakes and make the romance feel earned. Further, for a more innovative and creative approach to the romance formula, make sure your characters are motivated by more than romance. Consider the other long-term goals of your characters, and how the potential romance could help them achieve those goals, frustrate their efforts, or lead to a reassessment of those priorities.
Dialogue should reveal depth. Whether through open communication or witty banter, the way characters speak reflects their emotional state. In The Hating Game, playful dialogue creates tension while exposing vulnerabilities. The dialogue evolves throughout the story, becoming more charged as their feelings shift from hatred to attraction. As they navigate their complex emotions, the playful nature of their exchanges intensifies, showcasing the push-and-pull dynamic of their relationship. This escalation builds anticipation for their eventual romantic connection.
A well-crafted backstory adds richness, helping readers understand motivations. Whether characters are seeking second chances or are overcoming loss, their history deepens the emotional journey.
Finally, chemistry is key. As seen in Pride and Prejudice with Elizabeth and Darcy, complementary traits and contrasting personalities drive conflict and connection, in one of the most timelessly popular romance stories of all time. The novel explores themes of love, class, social expectations, and personal growth, which resonate across cultures and eras. The tension between societal norms and individual desires is a conflict that continues to resonate, making the story relatable to modern readers. But at its heart, relatable, complex characters have helped pride and prejudice maintain its appeal over centuries.
Character Development Checklist
What is your character’s greatest flaw?
Does this flaw create obstacles in their romantic journey?
How does their backstory shape their views on love?
Are they dealing with past heartbreak, trust issues, or something else?
What are their emotional vulnerabilities?
How does this vulnerability affect their interactions with the love interest?
How do your characters communicate?
Do they hide their emotions behind humor, or are they direct and open?
What complementary traits create chemistry?
How do their differences drive tension and attraction?
Building Chemistry and Conflict: The Heart of Romance
Chemistry in romance is more than just attraction; it’s about using meaningful moments to build a sense of connection. This can be through subtle gestures, shared vulnerabilities, or playful interactions. For instance, in Red, White & Royal Blue, the chemistry between Alex and Henry builds through their banter and profound conversations, revealing layers of their personalities over time. The key is to craft interactions that allow readers to feel the characters’ growing connection, whether it’s through dialogue, shared experiences, or gestures that speak volumes.
The Characters Meet
One key opportunity to build chemistry (and your reader’s interest) is your characters’ first meeting. This sets the tone for the relationship and for your brand of storytelling. While there isn’t one right way to write this first meeting, you’ll once again want to ask yourself what kind of romance you’re writing, and what your audience is looking for. In some cases, a classic “meet-cute” might be in order, in others, the first meeting might be an opportunity to build tension and ambiguity.
A contemporary yet classic example of a first meeting can be found in The Unhoneymooners by Christina Lauren. The main characters, Olive and Ethan, meet at a wedding where Olive’s sister is marrying Ethan’s brother. Their first encounter is filled with tension and humor, as Olive is thrust into the spotlight while trying to navigate her discomfort and dislike for Ethan.
This meeting is notable for its sharp, witty dialogue and immediate conflict, as they are forced to interact despite their mutual disdain. When a series of mishaps lead to a free honeymoon trip for the two of them, their initial animosity and banter set the stage for an evolving relationship and unexpected chemistry.
Conflict Builds Tension
From there, conflict keeps the romance engaging. Internal conflicts, such as fear of vulnerability or past trauma, add emotional depth. External conflicts—like social pressures or life circumstances—create tension that raises the stakes. In The Kiss Quotient, Stella’s internal struggle with intimacy due to her autism is compounded by external pressures from her family and society, making her relationship with Michael more complex and compelling.
The balance between chemistry and conflict is essential. Too much chemistry without tension can make the romance feel flat, while too much conflict without moments of connection can frustrate readers. The goal is to create moments of relief—small emotional breakthroughs—where the characters bond, even if obstacles still loom.
Comparison Chart: Chemistry and Conflict Progression in a Romance Novel
| Plot Point | Chemistry | Conflict | Examples |
| Introduction | Characters notice initial attraction. Small moments hint at emotional connection. | Conflict is low, often situational misunderstandings or minor external factors that keep the characters apart. | In Red, White & Royal Blue, Alex and Henry’s initial interactions are filled with tension, but the attraction simmers beneath their banter. |
| Growing Chemistry | Chemistry intensifies through shared moments, revealing vulnerabilities. Banter, subtle touches, and deep conversations build the emotional connection. | Conflict starts to rise, often driven by internal fears (e.g., fear of vulnerability) or external factors (e.g., societal pressures). | In The Kiss Quotient, Stella and Michael’s chemistry grows as they spend more time together, yet their personal fears complicate the relationship. |
| Midpoint Conflict | Chemistry peaks. The characters’ feelings are undeniable, heightening emotional stakes. | Conflict escalates, often due to misunderstandings or external challenges. Internal fears resurface, causing friction. | In The Unhoneymooners, the protagonists’ chemistry builds, but a sudden revelation threatens their growing connection. |
| Climax | Chemistry takes a back seat as the characters face their biggest challenge. Emotional distance might grow temporarily. | Conflict reaches its peak. This is the “all or nothing” moment, where internal and external forces push the characters to confront their feelings and obstacles. | In Beach Read, Gus and January face their deepest emotional challenges, testing the strength of their chemistry. |
| Resolution | Chemistry resurges as the conflict resolves. The characters are fully emotionally connected, with their relationship solidified. | Conflict is resolved, typically through personal growth or mutual understanding. External challenges are overcome. | In The Hating Game, the chemistry between the characters culminates as their conflict is resolved, leading to a satisfying romantic resolution. |
Discover the step-by-step guide to publishing success with Izzard Ink. From planning to marketing, we’ve got you covered.
Setting the Stage: Creating a World that Enhances Romance
The setting in a romance novel serves as far more than mere backdrop—it shapes the emotional tone and the dynamics between characters. Whether it takes place in a small town or a sprawling city, the setting can amplify chemistry and conflict.
Reflection of Emotion
The setting should mirror or contrast with the characters’ emotional states. For example, a cozy cabin may intensify intimacy, while a crowded city emphasizes emotional distance. In The Flatshare, the shared apartment forces characters into close proximity, building both tension and chemistry.
Atmosphere and Mood
Choose a setting that complements the romance’s tone. A rainy city can add melancholy, while a sunny beach evokes hope and possibility. In Beach Read, the seaside town becomes a space for emotional healing, enhancing the characters’ relationship.
Symbolism in Setting
Use elements like weather or landscapes to reflect relationship arcs. A storm might symbolize turmoil, while a blooming garden represents growth. In A Court of Thorns and Roses, nature mirrors the intensity of the characters’ emotions and challenges. The natural world often mirrors the feelings of the characters—when they are in love or experiencing joy, the surroundings are described in rich, flourishing detail, while darker moments are marked by stark or chaotic imagery.
World-Building for Fantasy and Paranormal Romance
In these genres, the setting shapes both the romance and the conflict. The magical or dystopian world introduces unique challenges for characters. For example, in A Court of Thorns and Roses, the fae world’s dangers directly affect the characters’ romantic development. The world-building enhances the romance by creating stakes and tensions that intertwine with the characters’ emotional journeys.
Key Considerations
How does the setting reflect or challenge your characters?
What mood or symbolism does the setting create?
How does the world-building shape the romance?
A well-crafted setting deepens the emotional stakes and makes the romance feel more immersive, enhancing both chemistry and conflict.
Writing Authentic Dialogue: Words that Spark Connection
Dialogue is essential in romance. It reveals vulnerability, builds chemistry, and creates emotional depth. How characters speak—what’s said and left unsaid—creates the intimacy that drives the story.
Vulnerability and Growth through Dialogue
Dialogue should evolve with the characters. Early conversations may be guarded, but their words reflect growing emotional openness as the relationship deepens. In The Bromance Book Club, playful banter gives way to more profound, heartfelt exchanges, showing emotional growth. Through dialogue, readers see how the characters evolve, confront their feelings, and support one another, making the relationships feel authentic and multi-dimensional.
Distinct Voices for Characters
Each character’s dialogue should reflect their unique background and personality, with a clear and distinct voice. In Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine, Eleanor’s formal speech contrasts with Raymond’s relaxed tone, highlighting their differences while building chemistry. Raymond’s casual speech and supportive nature create a comfortable space for Eleanor, making their exchanges feel authentic.
Subtext and Emotional Tension
Subtext—what’s left unsaid—adds depth to the dialogue, and is often central to your character’s romance arc. In Me Before You, Will’s reserved words conceal his emotions, while Louisa’s optimistic chatter gradually draws him into vulnerability.
Key Considerations
Voice: Is each character’s speech style distinct and authentic?
Subtext: Are emotions conveyed beneath the surface of the conversation?
Tone Evolution: How does the tone shift as the characters grow closer?
Tension and Relief: Are moments of emotional tension balanced with moments of connection?
Innovating Without Losing the Romance Formula
The ending of a romance novel delivers the emotional payoff readers crave. Whether it’s a happy-ever-after (HEA) or a bittersweet farewell, the conclusion should feel earned and provide resonating emotional closure for readers.
Earned Resolution Through Emotional Growth
For a satisfying ending, the resolution should come from the characters’ emotional growth. Their final decisions should reflect how they’ve overcome internal and external conflicts, making the outcome feel deserved, as a direct result of earlier struggles.
In The Time Traveler’s Wife, Clare and Henry’s love endures through immense challenges, leading to a bittersweet ending that feels emotionally satisfying because of their journey together. Similarly, in The Proposal by Jasmine Guillory, the characters overcome their fears of commitment, resulting in a fulfilling HEA. The use of dual perspectives allows readers to see both characters’ thoughts and feelings, providing deeper insight into their motivations and vulnerabilities, making the eventual resolution feel earned and satisfying.
HEA vs. Bittersweet Endings
An HEA resolves conflicts and unites the couple, providing emotional satisfaction, while a bittersweet ending acknowledges the complexities of life and love. Both can leave a lasting impact if they align with the story’s emotional tone. One Day by David Nicholls exemplifies a bittersweet conclusion where love remains, but external circumstances prevent a fully resolved ending, offering a poignant emotional takeaway. Instead of the typical meet-cute leading directly to a romantic resolution, the novel explores how their lives intertwine and diverge over time, emphasizing the impact of life’s complex circumstances on love.
Resolving Conflicts
All key conflicts, especially those central to the romance, should be resolved by the conclusion. Unresolved issues can leave readers frustrated, but neatly resolving the primary emotional and romantic tensions creates a gratifying experience.
Leaving Room for Imagination
While the main conflict should be resolved, a hint of ambiguity can allow readers to imagine the characters’ future beyond the final page, keeping them engaged even after the story ends.
More than a Romance
If your characters are motivated only by the romance in their lives, they may fall flat for readers. It’s important to ensure your characters, particularly your protagonist, are well-rounded, three-dimensional characters with goals, dreams, and aspirations beyond romance. Rather than distracting from the core romance, this approach offers storytelling opportunities and ensures the characters are relatable and well-developed.
For example, perhaps the budding romance actually interferes with main character’s other goals. A romantic interest appears, disrupting aspects of the protagonist’s life, but offering an unexpected path to romance. Having your characters begin at odds adds a chance to build tension and keep the reader guessing.
Wildcat: An Appalachian Romance
Izzard Ink Author Jeffrey Dunn, author of Wildcat: An Appalachian Romance, describes how romance can serve a story’s broader themes:
“The ‘romance’ in Wildcat points to a community in the midst of a communal experiment, an effort which follows on the heels of the Rust Belt industrial disaster of the 1980s. Like Nathaniel Hawthorne’s narrator in Blithedale Romance, Wildcat’s narrator is both inside and outside the community, in concert with the ecology, the people, and their aspirations but also apart in social class, education, and shared experience. This inside/outside dynamic is what provides the necessary tension.”
Key Considerations
Character Growth: Does the resolution reflect the emotional journey of the characters?
Conflict Resolution: Are all central romantic conflicts addressed?
Tone: Does the ending match the emotional tone of the story?
Future Possibilities: Is there room for readers to imagine the characters’ future?
Embrace the Romance Journey
The journey to writing a romance novel is more than storytelling—it’s about connecting with readers on a deep emotional level. You’ll create a romance that lingers in your readers’ hearts by focusing on audience connection, character development, and emotional pacing. Seek expert guidance to refine your story and ensure it shines in a competitive market.
Manuscript assessment is an exploration and uncovering of your manuscript’s potential. Our team of editors evaluates your work, providing specific, detailed feedback and actionable suggestions.
